Let them ref the games and be humans - Andrews
September 16, 2026 01:30
Brentford head coach Keith Andrews criticised current officiating practices after his side reached the Carabao Cup fourth round with a 2-1 win at Reading. Andrews said officials appear constrained by the game's technology and called for referees to be allowed to make on-field decisions and "be human beings."
The complaint followed a first-half incident in which Reading defender Paudie O'Connor had an overhead kick disallowed by referee Tom Nield for a high boot; Reading manager Leam Richardson described that decision as among the worst he has seen. Andrews also referenced a separate admission by Pro Ref that an "error of judgement" had been made in Manchester City's winning goal at Manchester United, a decision that fuelled debate about interference by an offside player.
KEY CONTEXT
- The EFL Cup stage in which Brentford and Reading met does not use VAR, so the disallowed O'Connor goal was decided on the pitch by Tom Nield.
- The wider controversy this week included Pro Ref acknowledging a mistaken call over Erling Haaland's goal in the Manchester derby, with discussion centring on whether Enzo Fernandez, in an offside position, interfered with play.
- Andrews argued that recent reliance on technology has changed referee habits, limiting their willingness to make on-field judgements.
WHY IT MATTERS
Decisions taken (or overturned) by officials can directly affect match outcomes and provoke strong reactions from managers and clubs. Andrews’ comments underline growing frustration among coaches about how referees balance the use of technology with on-field discretion, and they reflect fresh scrutiny after a high-profile admission of error in a Premier League fixture.
WHAT TO WATCH NEXT
- Whether officials' approach to on-field decision-making changes in response to criticism from managers such as Andrews.
- Any formal responses or clarifications from officiating bodies about the incidents mentioned have not been reported in this story.
KEY FACTS
- Brentford beat Reading 2-1 to progress to the Carabao Cup fourth round.
- Paudie O'Connor had a first-half overhead kick ruled out for a high boot by referee Tom Nield.
- No VAR is used at this stage of the EFL Cup.
- Pro Ref admitted an "error of judgement" over Manchester City's winner at Manchester United, prompting debate about offside interference by Enzo Fernandez.
- Andrews said Brentford are seventh in the Premier League and started the season unbeaten with one win and three draws.